|
FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS
|
| About test selection and placing orders |
|
|
|
Why should I like to participate in a Proficiency Test?
Participation in an iis Proficiency
Test allows a laboratory to compare its own performance to those of other, similar
laboratories. The presence of systematic errors and/or random errors will be revealed,
which allows the laboratory to take - if it feels necessary - corrective actions to
improve its performance.
Furthermore, the results are compared to
the requirements of internationally accepted analytical standard test methods (ISO, DIN,
ASTM or other industrial standards). Each laboratory gets a performance score (z-score).
Hopefully, this score - given by an independent institute - proves the laboratories good
performance. Prove which can be used to convince your staff, your clients and you National
Accreditation Body. See also other relevant information on
this site: Proficiency Test and
Statistics
How do I subscribe to
an iis interlaboratory study?
Please fill in the form on the e-mail page
and mail it us or send us a purchase order by mail or by fax. We will confirm your
registration by fax and in due time you will receive the respective samples.
Are iis' Proficiency
Tests recognised by the National Accreditation Bodies?
Yes. Since January 28, 2000, the iis quality system is in full agreement with ISO Guide 43 and ILAC G 13:2000. The
accreditation was officially recognised by the Dutch Council voor Accreditation ('Raad
voor Accreditatie', RvA). Our registration number is R007.
Through the existing M.R.A.'s also most
other National Accreditation Boards do recognise the accreditation of iis.
The Chinese National Laboratory Accreditation CNLA has no MRA with the RvA and has therefore
separately recognised iis as CNLA approved provider of PT schemes.
Is participation in
Proficiency Tests obliged for ISO 17025?
Regular participation to Proficiency Tests
is prescribed in the ISO 17025 and EN45001 guidelines. National accreditation bodies (NAB)
will audit whether your laboratory participates in relevant schemes and how the evaluation
of the results is implemented in your quality system. The iis Proficiency Tests are
presented to numerous NAB's.
Can I order Reference
Materials from iis?
The Institute for Interlaboratory Studies
is specialised in the organisation of interlaboratory studies and the development of
Reference Materials (RM's). However, the scope of available RM's is limited and the RM's
are only available for participants in one of the iis schemes.
See also other relevant information on this site:
Reference material Page
Does iis organise interlaboratory studies (Proficiency Tests) on request?
Yes, off course. If you have special
wishes, please get in contact to us. See also other relevant information on
this site: Info on Proficiency Tests
|
| About payment |
|
|
|
What is the VAT number of iis?
The VAT number of iis is NL004407726B02.
When should I pay?
We will issue an invoice during the execution of the proficiency test. Invoices should be payed within 30 days after receipt.
How should I pay?
We accept payment in Euros and in US Dollars. We prefer bank credit transfers.
What are the bank details of iis?
See the 'Contact us'
page for our bank details.
Why do I get invoices from SGS?
The Institute for Interlaboratory Studies
is a small, but fully independent department of the SGS Group, world's largest organisation in the field of
inspection, testing, analysis and certification.
|
| About samples and sample transport |
|
|
|
Why is the sample quantity limited?
As the results of our proficiency tests are used by accreditation bodies, we -as accredited organization- are not allowed to send a surplus of sample
in order to avoid excessive testing to get good results. The sample amounts are sufficient to perform all tests once.
Why are not all requested components present in the samples?
Our institute is
accredited acc. to ISO Guide 43 en ILAC G13. In the accreditation documents
is a requirement that tells us to use sample materials that are very
realistic and like every day's routine samples. However as in practice
hardly ever any forbidden components (e.g. AZO-dyes, metals or pesticides)
are found in textile, this would mean that we should use samples without any
contaminations at all. And that would not be suitable sample material in our
opinion, because we cannot evaluate laboratory performance with only 'less
than' results! Therefore we decided to use samples artificially contaminated
with several components, and to use each round different components with
different concentrations. In this way the samples are like every day's
routine samples for some components and at the same time give useful
information for other components.
What can I do when the sample quantity is too small for my laboratory to perform all tests?
The participating
laboratories do not have to perform all tests that are requested. Only tests
that are performed routinely by the laboratory should be reported. And the
laboratory may choose to perform only the tests that are most important for
the laboratory. When the laboratory wants to have extra material for
training purposes, the laboratory may request such material after closure of
the deadline of reporting results. All remaining material is retained by iis
and made available for the participating laboratories to be purchased. The
amount of remaining material is limited and varies strongly per product.
Please contact iis for more information.
What can I do when the samples arrived too late?
Please report to us about the delay and test the samples as usual. We will evaluate all reported results, also when reported after the deadline for submitting results.
What can I do when the samples arrived damaged?
Contact us as soon as possible. We will send you new samples ASAP.
How can I avoid samples being delayed by customs?
Participants are responsible for the customs clearance of the samples. For some countries the receiver needs to have an import licence. If you require us to attach documents to your parcel, we need to receive the documents at least two weeks before the sample dispatch date.
|
| About submission of results |
|
|
|
Can I report my results electronically?
Yes. Although we have not a page on our web site to upload your results, we very much welcome all results that are sent
to us by e-mail. In order to facilitate electronic reporting, all report forms are available in Word format on our website. See this
download page to download the required form.
Can I report my results after deadline?
Yes, you can report results after deadline.
Of course we prefer that you will report results before deadline, but due to unforeseen circumstances it may happen that you are not able to report your results before deadline. Please be assured that we will evaluate your results always after receipt, also when we receive your results long after deadline. We will send you a special report (usually one page for one sample) with our findings.
Of course your results will not be published in the regular final report.
Where do I find the report forms?
You should receive the report forms together with the samples. But occasionally the parcels are opened by customs and the forms do get lost. Therefore we also put the forms on our web site.
See this download page to download the required form.
Did iis receive my results?
Results that re received by fax are not confirmed by us. However, when you report results by e-mail, we will always confirm receipt of your results.
|
| About reports and statistics |
|
|
|
Why does iis not use Youden Plots?
Youden plots are meant for a two sample design, whereas iis organises proficiency tests using a single sample design.
The reason for this choice is our bad experiences with Youden plots. In some other interlaboratory studies the laboratories are asked to perform a duplicate analysis on one sample and the two results are considered a Youden pair, which is a wrong assumption. Furthermore the duplicates usually are contaminated with falsified results. The only reason for this falsification is a psychological one! Any sound thinking person will think twice before reporting bad duplicate results and will perform a re-test before reporting. So, in practice the reported duplicates are much better matching than the original duplicates. When the statistician subsequently uses a Cochran outlier test to delete all duplicates that do not fit in the data set, the only truly reported duplicate values will be seen as outliers and rejected!
The same may occur when two samples are sent to the laboratories and both individual result are used as Youden pair. Even when the sample set consists of blind replicates. Perhaps it may work once, but after the first final report, the participating labs know that duplicate samples are used and will treat all subsequent samples as duplicates. The only way to avoid this problem is to send more than 2 samples (e.g. 3,4,5....) and let the results/concentrations/values differ only marginally. In this way the labs will not know which samples are duplicates and which are not. Youden plots can also be made for samples that are not replicates, but with values that differ slightly! But this last option will give the labs a lot of work (testing at least 3 samples for the same tests!).
So, there are some negative aspects to the use of Youden sample pairs. And as iis does not see many positive aspects (the only one we see is the determination of repeatability, but one does not need an interlaboratory study for that!), iis decided not to use Youden pairs and save the labs a lot of work by testing only one sample.
Why is iis using target z-score and not the usual
z-score calculations in which standard deviation of the group of
laboratories is used?
This way of z-score
calculation results in a simple, straight forward comparison of lab results
with the reproducibility stated in the corresponding international accepted
test method. It indicates how many times the standard deviation the reported
result deviates from the 'true value'. Target z-scores allow evaluation of
performance over longer periods using a series of pt-results. This is
impossible with z-score calculated from the standard deviation of the group
of participants as the group of participants is not constant, nor is its
performance. See also
R.G.Visser, W.Oussoren, Accred Qual Assur 3:497-498.
What is the difference between a proficiency test and a collaborative trial?
In a proficiency test the performance of the participating laboratories is evaluated, while in a collaborative trial the performance characteristics of a Standard Test Method are determined.
Consequently in a proficiency test the laboratories use their usual test methods and the determination of a reliable assigned value is the ultimate goal,
while in a collaborative trial only one test method is used - being the one under investigation - and the determination of the repeatability and the reproducibility is the ultimate goal.
How can my laboratory show its good performance to clients?
Certificates of Excellence and certificates of Participation (see downloadable examples via this link:
certificates) are available as of October 1, 2004.
Only when all results reported by the laboratory are within the target reproducibility
limits a certificate of Excellence may be issued.
|
| About all other matters |
|
|
|
Can others see how I performed in an iis Proficiency Test?
The answer is simple: "NO!"
iis handles all information supplied by
the participating laboratories with great care and strictly confidential. No information
is passed to third parties unless prior permission is received.
The identity of individual participants is
always maintained confidential and only known to a minimum of authorised iis-personnel.
Furthermore, in all reports laboratories will only be represented by a code number.
The Institute is aware of the fact that
participants of proficiency test do not always wish to enclose their performance to third
parties. The identity of a laboratory can only be made public by the laboratory itself.
What is the most effective way to follow up my PT-results?
In order to assist the participating laboratories getting maximum efficiency from their PT-participation, Rob Visser - manager of iis - wrote some guidelines
that were published in an article in the international journal 'Accreditation and Quality Assurance'.
|